Issue: Human exposure to hormonally active chemicals is contributing
to the rise in prostate cancer rates.
Background:
Prostate cancer is an androgen-dependent disease that is rare before
age 50 years, incidence rates increasing steeply at older ages.
The lifetime risk of developing prostate cancer is estimated to
be 11% and the likelihood of dying from this disease is 3.6%. There
will be an estimated 189,000 new cases and 30,200 deaths from prostate
cancer in United States during 2002. Prostate cancer incidence and
mortality rates among U.S. Blacks are the highest in the world.
As assessed by studies of familial clusters, genetic factors alone
likely explain less than 10% of prostate cancers.
Disease trends:
Prostate cancer incidence rates have increased substantially in
several countries since about 1970. Introduction and widespread
use of the PSA (prostate-specific antigen) blood test that enables
early prostate cancer detection is thought to account for sharply
increased prostate cancer incidence rates observed during the late
1980's. Prostate cancer death rates also increased after 1970 but
less dramatically than incidence rates. Both incidence and mortality
rates appear to have declined slightly during the past few years.
Moreover, it is now clear that there are at least two forms of the
disease, a slow growing cancer that remains in the prostate gland
which is very common and a rapidly-growing, metastasizing form that
causes clinically-relevant prostate cancer. The relationship between
these two forms of the disease is not clear. The reasons for prostate
cancer increases before the late 1980's may have included both a
true increased risk and improved diagnosis because of safer surgical
procedures and a more aggressive approach toward treatment of older
men.
Consistency of the data: Most prostate cancers are dependent
on male hormones (androgens) that bind to androgen receptors in
prostate cells and stimulate their growth and function. Anti-androgen
drugs have been use to treat benign and malignant prostate disease
and are being tested for ability to prevent prostate cancer. There
is preliminary evidence that altered male hormone balance may increase
prostate cancer risk. This raises the possibility that mutations
in the AR gene or exposure to environmental chemicals with hormonally
active chemicals could modulate prostate cancer risk; for instance,
recent evidence suggests that the elevated risk among U.S. Blacks
may be caused in part by racial differences in AR gene polymorphisms.
Increased prostate cancer risks have also been linked to polymorphisms
in CYP17 and GSTP I, genes that encode enzymes that can activate
or inactivate environmental carcinogens.
No strong external
risk factors have been identified for prostate cancer. Most known
or suspected risk factors could act through hormonal mechanisms
but direct evidence is generally lacking; they could also act through
non-hormonal mechanisms such as genotoxicity. There is limited,
often inconsistent epidemiologic evidence for dietary factors that
may reduce (vegetables, fruits, tomato products, cabbage, brussels
sprouts, cauliflower, beans, peanuts, soy foods, selenium, vitamin
E, beta-carotene, lycopenes) or increase (animal fat, red meats,
dairy products, calcium, cured meat) the risk of prostate cancer.
Five cohort studies of vegetarians, however, showed no reduction
of prostate cancer risks. Diets high in fat and simple carbohydrates
tend to raise insulin and insulin-like growth factor levels; the
latter promote increased sex steroid synthesis, stimulate cell proliferation
and have been linked to increased prostate cancer risks. Occupational
exposures linked to increased risk of prostate cancer include: farming,
pesticides, metal fabricating, and activities involving exposure
to metallic dusts, cutting oils, and paints/varnishes. Evidence
linking smoking to incident prostate cancer is mixed but risk was
increased 2-3 times among men with high body mass index who started
smoking before age 20 years or were heavy smokers. There is mixed
evidence of a role for alcohol consumption in prostate cancer.
Experimental
evidence: Prostatic hypertrophy has been demonstrated in various
rodent experiments following treatment with estrogenic chemicals.
These effects have been shown to occur at low concentrations. However,
it should be noted that, although similar experimental protocols
have been followed, other investigators have been unable to reproduce
these findings. Moreover, even though the dose levels are considered
to be low relative to the concentrations necessary to induce other
adverse effects with these toxicants, the concentrations still considerably
exceed the concentrations present in low dose birth control pills
and thus these changes may not necessarily be considered low dose
effects.
Changes in prostate
gland growth in rodents have been suggested to indicate that similar
changes may occur in humans. However, the extent to which chemical
effects on rodent prostate gland development can be used to predicting
risk of human prostate cancer is not clear, given the differences
in gland anatomy and the fact that few rodents spontaneously develop
prostate cancer. Furthermore, the mechanism of environmental contaminant
induced changes in prostate gland differentiation and growth have
yet to be elucidated.
Biological
plausibility: In the absence of direct human evidence (demonstrated
exposure, association between exposure and increased risk of prostate
cancer, and evidence of contaminant induced changes in circulating
levels of sex steroids of affected men compared to a reference population),
there remains the theoretical possibility that hormonally active
chemicals may modulate prostate cancer risk by altering sex steroid
balance in men. However, the hypothesis that human exposure to hormonally
active environmental chemicals is associated with an increased risk
for the development of prostate cancer remains to be tested.
Conclusion:
Despite much research, the main proven risk factors for prostate
cancer risk are non-modifiable: age, family history, and race. Epidemiologic
research on potential modifiable risk factors has shown associations
with diet, occupation, lifestyle and other factors. At present,
the inconsistencies and inadequacies of existing studies do not
permit a conclusion that hormonally active chemicals are potential
causative factors in prostate cancer.
For more information on Prostate Cancer click here
Key Papers on this issue: